You are currently viewing In West Bengal, the issue of felling of trees on the India-Bangladesh border, the SC asked the Central Government questions

In West Bengal, the issue of felling of trees on the India-Bangladesh border, the SC asked the Central Government questions

Learn Additionally: SC orders Franklin Templeton to return Rs 9122 crore to buyers

The courtroom mentioned that prima facie we don’t take into account it a stayer. We don’t agree that you do not want EIA if the undertaking is lower than 100 km, we’ll ask somebody to problem it or issue a discover themselves. The Supreme Courtroom mentioned that they need to put together a protocol for such initiatives and be sure that choices are thought of that are much less environmentally dangerous. The Supreme Courtroom has asked the petitioner’s lawyer Prashant Bhushan to organize a draft protocol. The subsequent listening to will likely be two weeks later.

Learn Additionally: Krishna Govardhan Highway Undertaking: SC’s query to UP authorities, ‘Why ought to trees be minimize and roads made straight ..’

Truly, the report of the knowledgeable committee on the issue of heritage trees on West Bengal and a separate report of Sunita Narayan, a member of the committee, has been given. The mentioned knowledgeable committee was appointed by the Supreme Courtroom on the petition of the Affiliation for Safety of Democratic Rights. The petition requested to guard 4036 trees (about 200 years outdated or extra outdated and endangered trees included) to be pruned for highway widening undertaking and development of railway over bridge (ROB) in West Bengal Huh. In the report, the knowledgeable committee has additionally performed a value / profit evaluation retaining in thoughts the pure capital.

The report takes into consideration the monetary worth of a completely grown tree, which has usually been neglected by undertaking proponents. In accordance with their evaluation, the worth of 300 totally grown trees which is 100 years earlier than their pure age is not less than 2.2 billion (220 crores). Earlier, throughout the listening to in the case of felling of trees for the development of railway over bridge (RoB) on the Indo-Bangladesh border in West Bengal, the nation’s Chief Justice SA Bobde had mentioned. Inexperienced cowl have to be protected. This decline is going on so quick that many issues will go away completely earlier than anybody finds out. Individuals are not prepared to discover choices. There might be some strategy to make a path with out slicing trees.

In reality, round 800 deaths occurred close to railway traces. The federal government determined to assemble a 4 km foot overbridge, which required slicing of many trees. The courtroom mentioned that we wish to see if we will comply with sure rules. We want some strategies. There might be some strategy to make a path with out slicing trees. It may be a bit dearer, however if you happen to worth the property, it will be higher. The bench mentioned that they’d take into account the report of the knowledgeable panel. In reality, on 9 January 2022, the Supreme Courtroom has constituted a committee of environmental specialists for the development of a railway over bridge (RoB) on the India-Bangladesh border in West Bengal and widening of Nationwide Freeway-112 from Barasat to Petrapole. Will counsel the possibility of slicing trees.

The bench mentioned that after we minimize down a heritage tree, think about the worth of oxygen produced by the tree in all these years. The bench asked the four-member committee, which incorporates Sunita Narayan, an environmentalist at the Middle for Science and Atmosphere, to submit its report in 4 weeks. The bench had mentioned that this case presents a basic dilemma between environmental degradation and growth. Clearly every scenario includes completely different views. It states that no matter technique is to be adopted for the evaluation of injury to the setting, it’s fascinating that the proposed harvesting choices of heritage trees be thought of by specialists.

Learn Additionally: Three associates made ‘world’s worst Airbnb’ by placing a mattress underneath the tree, folks began reserving on seeing this, see video

Throughout the listening to, the bench had asked the West Bengal authorities to think about the worth of the tree of oxygen in all these years when slicing a heritage tree. Examine this to how a lot you would need to pay for the oxygen equal of these trees, if you happen to had to purchase it elsewhere. Prashant Bhushan, a lawyer for the Affiliation for Safety of Democratic Rights (APDR), initially mentioned there was no various and Permission was given to felling trees, that are heritage of about 80-100 years of age. He mentioned that everybody is aware of about international warming and the research has mentioned that if the vegetation shouldn’t be protected, the human species will likely be at risk in the subsequent 10-20 years.

Bhushan urged that underpasses of bridges might be constructed as an alternative and the alignment of roads might be modified to keep away from felling of trees. On the different hand, senior advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi, showing for West Bengal, had mentioned that 800 folks die yearly because of this. The Calcutta Excessive Courtroom has thought of all facets after which it was allowed to felling 356 trees, which is important for the development of RoB and widening of the highway. In reality, on August 31, 2018, the Calcutta Excessive Courtroom opened the highway for widening of the nationwide freeway and allowed greater than 350 trees to be minimize for widening of Jessore Highway, on the situation that 5 trees can be planted as an alternative of each tree minimize. This highway connects the metropolis with Petrapole on the India-Bangladesh border. NH-112 or Jessore Highway is a crucial hyperlink between India and Bangladesh and the state authorities has initiated a undertaking to make it complete.

Learn Additionally: These trees and crops have non secular significance in India, folks’s religion is connected to them

There are rows of a whole lot of outdated trees on both facet of the highway, some of which have been determined to be minimize for the function of widening the highway. A PIL was filed earlier than the Excessive Courtroom difficult the state’s plan to chop trees. After a number of months of debate, the Excessive Courtroom allowed 356 trees to be harvested at 5 locations from Barasat to the Petrapole border alongside Jessore Highway.